Pantry Picks®

Welcome inside the kitchen of Bon Appetit Y‘all® and Pantry Picks®

Attention all Foodies, Grillers, Homemakers, Inquisitive Cooks, Recipe Enthusiasts and Culinary Daredevils:

Discover a hassle-free, flavorful cooking system that fits seamlessly into your busy life. Explore Exciting Paths to Ignite Creativity in Your Everyday Cooking (and Your Life)…

Introducing Pantry Picks® Everyday Gourmet Condiment Subscription, Designed Just for Home Cooks like You.

Dive into a world of playful Sassy Sauces, Seasonings, Sweets, and Savories that will ignite your inner culinary explorer and inspire you to rediscover the joy of cooking, and maybe even get a little creative with your dishes.

Subscribe NowGive as a Gift

What is "Pantry Picks®"?

Welcome to the world of "Pantry Picks®," a monthly subscription program crafted just for passionate home cooks like you. With Pantry Picks®, we're here to ignite your culinary enthusiasm and reignite your love for cooking.

Each month, anticipate a delightful delivery of two exclusive selections that will elevate your pantry game to new heights. Picture a treasure trove of hand-crafted, small-batch condiments made with the finest ingredients sourced from local farmers' markets and trusted purveyors.

These selections aren't your run-of-the-mill grocery store finds. They are the same exceptional ingredients we rely on daily in the catering kitchen of Occasional Occasions by Carlton (the parent company of Bon Appetit Y'all by Carlton). Whether you're a kitchen novice or a seasoned home chef, prepare to be astonished by the exceptional quality and creativity that Pantry Picks® brings to your culinary repertoire.

So, step into our kitchen, don your apron, and join the culinary adventure. With Bon Appetit Y'all by Carlton® and Pantry Picks®, get ready to infuse your cooking with sass, creativity, and a whole lot of fun!

Kathleen "It’s like Christmas each time I receive my Bon Appetit Y'all box! I can’t wait to open it up and use the latest goodies Carlton has packed this month. The picks are delicious - we’ve enjoyed each and every one! And the recipes Carlton includes are delicious and fun to make!" Kathleen Borsch - Johns Creek Georgia

Subscribe NowGive as a Gift

We’ve all been there staring into the fridge, hoping inspiration will leap out pondering what to whip up for dinner, especially on those busy weeknights? I’ve been there, too, and I know how it feels when inspiration seems to be playing hide-and-seek But fear not, there’s a solution.

Our system, along with our carefully selected seasonings and sauces, are the keys to conquering these everyday kitchen challenges.

With each Pantry Picks® shipment, you’ll receive specialized, yet delightfully simple, recipes. These recipes are your kitchen compass, guiding you on how to effortlessly infuse our mouthwatering products into your daily cooking routine. But that’s not all! As a cherished member, you’ll unlock an exclusive treasure: access to our private recipe vault and curated chef-led videos. These videos are a backstage pass to the culinary genius of our chefs, helping you master the art of using our exquisite ingredients and recipes like a pro. So, let’s banish blandness from your dishes and embark on a flavorful journey together!

Robert Ross "As a member of the subscription service, I have been very happy. Excellent surprises arrive each month. Having new and unusual choices has made it easy to expand my menus and engaged the entire family! I'll be restocking from the pantry!"
Robert Ross, Atlanta GA.

Our Pantry Picks® Everyday Gourmet Condiment Subscription will help you transform the ordinary into extraordinary.

Our promise to you…

At Pantry Picks®, our promise is simple: we’re dedicated to delivering the finest, handcrafted condiments made from top-quality ingredients sourced from local farmers’ markets and trusted purveyors.

But that’s just the start. We also understand the importance of your health, which is why our seasonings and marinades are crafted with salt substitutes or no salt, reduced sugar, also most of our products are Gluten Free and Vegan friendly. This way, you have the power to take control of your food, leading to healthier and tastier meals.

What’s more, your culinary journey with Pantry Picks® will take on a seasonal twist, ensuring that your palate is always in for a delightful surprise. For instance, during the summer months, we feature crowd favorites like Grilled Chicken with Peach Bourbon Barbecue Sauce, a quintessentially Southern delight that combines the rich flavors of Bourbon and Peaches.

Our house-made Herbalicious Dry marinade is another secret weapon in your kitchen arsenal. This versatile seasoning doubles as a marinade, packing so much flavor that you literally won’t need to season most things with anything else.

And the best part? Pantry Picks® has an ever-growing list of offerings, with dozens of exciting items planned for you every month. Here’s a sneak peek at some of the delicious treats in store:

  • Bacon Bourbon Whiskey BBQ Sauce
  • Rosemary Mustard BBQ Sauce
  • Root Beer BBQ Sauce
  • Chocolate Raspberry Jam
  • Strawberry Basil & Jalapeno Jam
  • Blueberry-Earl Grey Jam
  • Peach Bourbon & Ginger Jam
  • Honey Dijon White Balsamic Vinaigrette
  • Fig Balsamic Vinaigrette
  • Bacon Bourbon Ketchup
  • Peach Ketchup
  • Roasted Red Pepper Ketchup
  • Herbalicious Dry Marinade
  • Lemon & Garlic Seasoning
  • Lil Sumthin Sumthin Spice Rub
  • Garlic Pepper Seasoning
Shop your Pantry

And that’s just a glimpse of the flavor extravaganza that awaits you along with new creative releases throughout the year. Imagine the wonder on your family and friends’ faces at your next gathering when they savor your culinary creations—a true testament to your newfound cooking prowess! So, why wait? Dive into your flavor-packed journey with Pantry Picks® today and let the delicious adventures begin.

As a cherished Pantry Picks® member, here's an enticing glimpse of what awaits you:

•  Two Exclusive Pantry Selections

Every month, we handpick two exceptional pantry staples and one-of-a-kind non-perishable delicacies, all delivered straight to your doorstep.

These gems are sourced from our vast and exclusive collection, ensuring you won't find them anywhere else. Our selections encompass a diverse range of BBQ Sauces, Seasonings, Rubs, Jams, Jellies, Vinaigrettes, Mustards, Butters, Relishes, Pickles, House-Made Crackers, and more.

Prepare to be pleasantly surprised by the versatility of each item you receive, stretching far beyond traditional use.

•  The Padded Pantry® newsletter

Gain privileged access to our members-only newsletter, The Padded Pantry®. Here, you'll uncover a treasure trove of new and unique recipes, insider tips, and clever kitchen hacks.

•  Fun and easy Kitchen Hacks and tips to simplify your culinary life

Say goodbye to kitchen frustrations with our handy Kitchen Hacks and tips. These culinary secrets will save you time and hassles, leaving you to wonder how you ever managed without them!

•  Recipes and Pairing suggestions

We make it effortless to master your monthly Pantry Picks® with our detailed step-by-step recipes and pairing recommendations, along with our shopping list included with the recipes to make your cooking preparation effortless. We remove the guesswork, ensuring you make the most of every ingredient.

•  Our Private Recipe Vault Pick

Our Easy Search Private Recipe Vault, which makes it easy to find the recipes that fit your specific requirements, be it by dietary restrictions, cooking prep methods, specific proteins and so much more!

•  Cooking Videos of fun unique and different ways to utilize your Pantry Picks®

Join our chefs as they reveal the best ways to make your monthly picks even more memorable!

•  Advanced release notification of all new items

You will be the first to know about everything we bring to the market, with the option of purchasing at your members only discounted price before anyone else even knows it is available.

•  15% discount on any products available on the Pantry Picks® shelves, through a discount code provided with subscription.

•  A generous refer-a-friend program (coming soon!)

Join us on this flavorful journey, where every month brings a delightful surprise and endless culinary possibilities. Pantry Picks® is more than a subscription— it's a solution designed to bring ease and delight into your kitchen.

Subscribe NowGive as a Gift

Tricia Clements What do you get someone that has just about everything... and eats toast with jelly EVERY morning for breakfast? Pantry Picks® by Occasional Occasions by Carlton! I picked out the Peach Bourbon Ginger Jam, Pinot Noir Red Wine Jelly and Apple-Shallot Chutney. It was packaged with beautiful bright crinkle paper and looked so good that I used it when I put the jars in the gift bag.
Can't wait to try all of the items they have to offer: seasonings, jams, jellies, BBQ sauces and more!
Sign up for, or gift the monthly subscription - Pantry Picks®, or pick out individual items to Pad Your Pantry. These make wonderful gifts. Order, before the holiday rush, they're going to be extremely popular come gift season time."

Tricia Clements from Marietta Ga.


How to Get Started with Your Very Own Pantry Picks®?

Monthly Subscription Program: For just $29.95 (includes shipping), you'll unlock a world of culinary delights every month. The best part? You have the freedom to cancel at any time while keeping all the delightful goodies you've received up to that point.

Pantry Picks® is your comprehensive kitchen solution, designed to banish common culinary challenges and elevate your cooking game. With handpicked gourmet condiments, expertly crafted recipes, time-saving hacks, insightful videos, an exclusive newsletter, convenient shopping lists, a private culinary community, and a generous discount program, it's more than a subscription; it's a complete program for culinary success. From adding delightful flavors to simplifying your cooking process, Pantry Picks® has you covered, ensuring that each dish you create is a masterpiece. There is literally nothing else like this available anywhere. You can’t go wrong with trying or gifting a Pantry Picks® subscription.

The perfect gift for anyone who cooks!

Pantry Picks® makes an exceptional gift because it's the gift of culinary delight and endless possibilities. Imagine your loved ones exploring the world of gourmet condiments, discovering chef-curated recipes, and mastering time-saving kitchen hacks. It's a journey of flavor, creativity, and convenience that keeps on giving, month after month. With each Pantry Picks® delivery, they'll experience the joy of cooking like a pro, all while savoring exclusive tastes and insider tips. Whether it's for a foodie friend, a home chef, or someone seeking kitchen inspiration, Pantry Picks® is the perfect present to spark their culinary passion and elevate their everyday cooking.


Pantry Picks®

$29.95 / month